A Cup of History from Oaxaca's Legendary Horchatera, Casilda Flores

casilda flores horchatera

OAXACA,OA—Horchata is not exclusively a Mexican beverage, but it is an essential refreshment throughout the country. The milkish drink has roots in the Mediterranean where it was once made of barley, among other things. The Spanish brought the concept with them and a couple ingredients, namely rice and almonds. These ingredients, when soaked and ground, ended up being suitable as substitutes and Mexican horchata was born. 

South of Mexico, Hondurans, Salvadorians, and Nicaraguans all have their renditions of the drink. Salvadorians famously add morro seeds for a darker, spicier flavor. Even within Mexico there is some diversity in the production of horchata. No one is better suited to explain that than Casilda Flores Morales, the legendary horchatera of Oaxaca. Her experience presents a broad cross-section of Mexican agua fresca history. 

agua fresca in benito juarez market

Casilda has since passed away, but Oaxacan authorities had the wherewithal to publish a long interview with her during her life. Her generational knowledge of horchata and other agua frescas is an invaluable insight into the milky past of Mexican refreshments, with or without almonds.

In 1989, the Dirección General de Culturas Populares and Dirección de Educación, Cultura y Bienestar Social visited Casilda in her home to reflect on her family history selling drinks in Oaxaca. The interview drew on 100 years of intergenerational experience in the production and sale of these drinks and proves that something as seemingly simple as horchata can be innovated upon. 

Casilda told the interviewers that her family started selling local culinary staples back in 1890. At that time, they only sold pineapple beer, nicuatole, and agua de chilacayota. Nicuatole is not a drink (despite the term atole,) rather a gelatinous dessert. The other two, however, are drinks. Agua de chilacayota, a refreshment made from a gourd, is still extremely common throughout Oaxaca. Pineapple beer, however, is extinct. 

Even in 1989, at the time of the interview, Casilda stated that pineapple beer had long ago disappeared. Fermented pineapple is commonly called tepache, but Casilda insisted that this drink was unique. She stated, “And the difference that there is between pineapple beer and tepache is that the beer is made only with the rind of criolla pineapple and tepache includes castilla plantain peel, cinnamon, piloncillo, toasted corn, peppers, pineapple rind, and a piece of wood I can’t remember.” 

horchata de almendra con tuna
Horchata de almendra con tuna, almond horchata with prickly pear

While this refreshment has since disappeared, Casilda was able to comment on what she considered classic and traditional flavors of agua fresca. Among her “traditional” rankings were prickly pear with cassava and walnut, chia with lime, and almond horchata with prickly pear. She designated tamarind, pineapple, soursop, hibiscus, sapote, plum, melon, watermelon, and peach to be secondary tier refreshments. Locally, Casilda’s family is sort of lionized as having invented almond horchata with prickly pear. They still sell it to this day. 

Casilda claimed that her aunt was the one who came up with the family’s recipe for almond horchata with prickly pear. But we can’t be sure that they were the first to make the mix. Horchata is far older than the Flores family’s business, and almond horchata was concurrent with their early 20th century foray into horchata. Who can say if they added tuna to the drink first?

horchata made from almonds

Undoubtedly, their version is one of the most famous horchatas in all of Mexico. From the stand in Benito Juarez Market, Casilda’s family members keep the business and tradition alive. They have massive clay amphorae filled with the most popular flavors, a rotund demonstration of just how much business they can do in a day. Other flavors are presented in glass pitchers that display an array of colors. Overlooking the entire operation–a photo of Casilda. Her eyes look out across the aisle at the competing agua fresca stall that has opened across the way. 

The almond horchata with prickly pear is still a bestseller. It has all the smoothness of almond milk with more body. Slivers of cantaloupe surprise in the mix with walnuts sprinkled on top. The prickly pear is presented in a red syrup that sweetens the horchata and compliments the almond in the weirdest of ways. Looking around the stand, most everyone is enjoying the same drink.

It is not easy to make a name for yourself selling horchata. Most folks can make horchata at home or buy it at any convenient street corner. Casilda’s dedication to a seemingly simple livelihood and her family’s secret recipe have catapulted her into the pantheon of Oaxacan gastronomy. Lucky for all of us, the drink has outlived the horchatera and her words have been immortalized in ink. 

aguas de casilda in oaxaca

Read More:

chango mezcalero bottle in Oaxaca

The Rise and Fall of the Mezcal Monkey

The glass bottles of mezcal that grace your liquor store shelves have not always been that way. Within the last century, mezcal was stored in large 25+ liter jugs. As it became more popular in Mexican bars, ceramic artisans began styling liter sized bottles in the shapes of women, penises, and monkeys known as changos. For a couple decades, the chango ruled, but plastic and glass killed it. Santa Maria Coyotepec is the homeland of the chango mezcalero and other fine black ceramics.

Read More »
Expensive Chinese Tea

China’s Drinkable Antique: the extravagance of Pu erh

As tea was farmed and dried in the mountains of Southern China, it was shipped out on long, difficult journeys to the west towards India and the east towards Beijing. It would arrive in large cities in the teapots of sophisticated and influential households at the end of its journey, but on the way, exposure to time, the elements, and perhaps the sweat of pack animals transformed the tea. When a long leaf variety from the Camellia sinensis var. assamica plant was subjected to these conditions, the buyers found the flavor to be exquisite. Pu erh was born.

Read More »
Acatenango Volcano in Guatemala

Fire Water on a Volcano

We pass the bottle around the fire, swigging happily and reveling in the burning sensation that the liquor gives the throat. Soon, we are laughing at the wind and our bodies warm up to the idea of sleeping on the side of this volcano. We look from the fiery peak of Fuego to the clear bottle glimmering red in our campfire.

Read More »
West Virginia State Lottery Building

The Hot Spots of West Virginia

Around every bend in Morgantown, there is another Hot Spot. These establishments are bars with slot machines, or limited video lottery retailers. In order to offer gambling, they must have a license to sell alcohol. But the reason they are called “Hot Spots” is somewhat of a mystery. Businesses across the state have adopted the name to tell people what kind of bar they are.

Read More »

EXPLORE BEVERAGES BY REGION